I believe there is a difference between what some call “porn” and others call “erotica”. For me, erotica is of a higher aesthetic quality. Without trying to offer a comprehensive definition–that would be more appropriate for a much longer blog post, and I like to keep my posts at a certain manageable length–I believe the aim of erotica, if there is an aim, is to somehow, in someway to depict and portray one of the basic elements of life, eros, or to put it more broadly, the dynamics of human sexuality, but in a way that possesses some sort of artistic and aesthetic merit. It is not merely depicting sexuality for the sake of arousal among the viewer, although arousal is certainly a possibility, and a possibility that is completely legitimate. Rather, erotica tries to capture something of the deeper, even spiritual elements of sexuality, in way that transcends the more primal elements of sexual engagement. It portrays sex, nudity, and sexual interaction in a way that is more meaningful for the viewer. It touches something more basic in the psyche than merely base desires. It leaves one with a better aftertaste in the mind, even if the loins are stirred.
I believe beauty is an essential element of good erotica. Porn too often caters to what is ugly, bizarre, or even disgusting. It appeals to little more than the most base elements of sexual desire, without any redeeming emotional or spiritual qualities at all. In porn, portrayals of people fucking are often little more than barnyard exhibitions of human animals, screaming and grunting and copulating with the grace and elegance of a bovine orgy, the actors often exhibiting as much fleshly artificiality as cows pumped up on growth hormones.
I enjoy good erotic depictions, even very explicit ones. I dislike porn. For instance, here of some of the elements of most porn, elements that I find rather distasteful.
Porn: Close up images of a woman spreading her labia for no other purpose than to turn on the overweight tow truck driver who is guzzling down his ninth Budweiser while he jerks off to such images in his trailer home.
Porn: Close up images of a woman’s gaping anus after she has been triple penetrated.
Porn: Ass to mouth. This is when a man fucks a woman in the ass, and then puts his penis in her mouth so she can, “taste her ass”. This is even too vile for me. I love playing with a woman’s ass, but this is just plain old unhealthy. Why would anyone in their right mind risk dysentery for this? Hepatitis is also a rather nasty condition, even potentially lethal. Intestinal infections are not fun.
Porn: Fake breasts, huge hair, tough looking women, fingernails longer than the a samurai sword, hyperbolic screaming, strung out looking people clearly disintegrating from chronic drug use.
Porn: Too many tatoos and piercings.
Porn: “Cream pie” finishes where the woman then squeezes the semen out of her vagina for the pleasure of the viewers. It is this technical, almost gynecological aspect of most porn, a porn devoid of any true sensuality, that I find completely uninteresting. It is clearly geared to turn on the great majority of such porn viewers: the fat, bald men who have never been with a woman.
Porn: Violent anal sex. Ripping apart someone’s anus and rectum with, most likely, irreparable damage is not appealing to me. A lot of woman enjoy the forbidden nature of anal pleasures when done properly, but I think most women would find this act highly unappealing.
These are just a few example. There are many more, but you get the point.
Now, what I find pleasant in erotica is the pursuit of a natural erotic beauty. Sex is portrayed as something hot, enticing, pleasurable, and mutually gratifying for the couple. The scenes are natural. They seem real. The couples are often beautiful. The women appear healthy, happy and sensual. There are few tatoos, piercings, fake breasts, long fingernails, big hair. The fucking can be hot and heavy and explicit, and I enjoy this, but the atmosphere is imbued with erotic passion, even love. It leaves the mind with a pleasant feeling, like you have savored a good meal, or a fine glass of wine. There is a certain grace, even lyricism to good erotica. It is also rare. You must search quite a bit, and wade through much trash, to find good erotica. It is almost like searching for a hidden treasure amid a wasteland of weeds and broken glass, or searching for fresh food in a dumpster. And again, in the end, there is element of beauty in erotica, an element of beauty which is lacking in porn. I suppose these are all ineffable qualities, and subjective judgements are in the end difficult to define, but I do believe there is a qualitative difference between these two types of mental sexual stimulates.
Many people, especially those of a religious bent, lump both porn and erotica together. If there is any nudity or sexuality depicted in a photograph, or work of art, or even writing, they reject it as being evil and unnatural and harmful. I suppose the preponderance of porn tends to obscure the quality of good erotica, since porn is so ubiquitous and erotica is harder to find, so most people do not understand the difference between the two. This an unfortunate barrier for the enjoyment of good erotica. It is out there, however, and I urge my readers to discover it, especially the female readers. Women should, and do, enjoy good erotica too, whether visual or in writing.
Finally, I would like to point to the image posted above. It has artistic merit. The placement of the figures, the use of shadows, the way the woman’s hair blends in with the dark background, the contrast of shadows with her white shirt and fair skin, the partial exposure of her pleasant looking ass beneath the curve of her back while her panties are being pulled down, appeals to the imagination, while at the same time appealing to what we see as well. We see this image, and we can think, or imagine more. So our minds are appealed to, as well as our bodies. It is hot, sexy, even beautiful, it is sensual and delightful and erotic in the fullest sense. I leave this image feeling good.
I will write more on these things, much more, but for now let me say that I enjoy erotic things. I like erotic nudes. I like explicit erotic depictions of sex. They are beautiful, and I like beautiful things.
willcrimson said:
I don’t know… I think you make too many generalizations as concerns the type of people who view porn as opposed to erotica – bald, fat, truck drivers, etc… Not sure that it helps your argument.
To me.
Erotic – 1. Sexual. 2. The suggestion of sex.
Pornographic – 1. Sex. 2. The depiction of sex.
Something that is erotic may not be primarily about sex.
Something that is pornographic is always primarily about sex.
Erotica need not be visual.
Pornography is always visual (hence the root of the word).
I guess that’s where I would leave it. Here’s something to think about. My computer’s dictionary makes no distinction between erotica and pornography. It has this to say about both:
:creative activity (writing or pictures or films etc.) of no literary or artistic value other than to stimulate sexual desire
I was trying to think of some Erotica that has literary merit. There’s Bright Star, by Keats and Venus and Adonis, by Shakespeare (considered nothing more than erotica in its day).
It does distinguish between erotic and pornographic.
Erotic 1. giving sexual pleasure; sexually arousing
Pornographic 1. 1. designed to arouse lust
Racer X said:
Will,
Yeah, these are fine distinctions. As I mentioned in the post, in the end these are simply subjective thoughts which are difficult really to categorize.
I think erotica can depict in a graphic and explicit way sex, as much as porn. I just find that what I might consider erotica has a certain quality to it that is higher than your average porn. There is certainly much overlap between the two. What I might consider erotica could also be considered porn by someone else.
Those definitions you referenced are interesting. It seems to me that there is little difference between sexually arousing and arousing lust. Again, there is fine line between the two.
The harem's master said:
According to the bible looking with lust upon a woman who is not your wife is a big “Thou shalt NOT!!” Therefore porn is anything that makes a man look at another woman and drool.
I agree the lack of emotional involvement between the actors in most sexually explicit movies degrades the whole thing. (I’m not sure how to say what I wanted to say. Hope you can figure it out.)
If you’re into reading stories with sexually explicit content, I’d be interested in your opinion of my book, Harem Master.
willcrimson said:
Hey HM, if you’re looking for a review, the standard thing would be to send Racer X a free copy of your book.
The harem's master said:
Where and how?
willcrimson said:
Where and how?
You’ll have to ask Racer X. I don’t even know if he’s willing. All I’m saying is that usually authors or publishers who are looking for reviews don’t expect the reviewer to pay for the book. They send it, gratis. Maybe it will be reviewed, maybe not, but that’s how it’s done.
Rebekah said:
For me, the distinction between “porn” and erotica is the way it makes me feel. One makes me feel embarrassed and ashamed – degraded, if you will – and the other makes me feel sensual and excited/curious about my sexuality.
Porn seems to depict things being done to a person; erotica has the feel of things being explored with a person. In porn, everything feels objectified and there for the sake of merely getting off; erotica is so much more – and often very tasteful and artistic.
Of course, my experience with porn – such as the type you’ve described above – is very limited, even non-existent, so I’m no expert. I just know from the experiences I’ve had the feeling evoked by porn vs. erotica is totally different.
Racer X said:
Rebekah,
That is an interesting view on the difference between porn and erotica.
“Porn seems to depict things being done to a person; erotica has the feel of things being explored with a person. ”
I agree with that. It seems to be valid distinction.
“the other makes me feel sensual and excited/curious about my sexuality. ”
Really. I will do what I can to do to help you feel more sensual and sexually curious..